There are at least sixteen journalists imprisoned in Egypt in relation to their reporting, according to a special report released Thursday by the Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ). Another two, the report says, have been released pending investigation. CPJ says this is the highest number recorded by the group in the past twenty-five years, when it began documenting press freedom in Egypt. The Prosecutor General and Minister of Transitional Justice, however, told CPJ that there are no journalists detained in Egypt for doing their jobs.
Of the eighteen journalists, Mohamed Abu Zeid, also known as Shawkan, has been detained the longest, and has yet to be formally charged. Abu Zeid was arrested on August 14, 2013, while covering the dispersal of the pro-Mohamed Morsi sit-in at Raba’a al-Adaweya Square. The CPJ report says that, according to media reports, Abou Zeid is under investigation for “weapons possession, illegal assembly, murder, and attempted murder.”
At least five of the journalists were arrested on the job, while three were arrested in their homes. One journalist, Mosad al-Barbary, was arrested in Beirut, near the Rafik Hariri airport, and was extradited based on a bilateral extradition treaty between Egypt and Lebanon.
Of the eighteen journalists, at least eleven of them have already been sentenced. The sentences range from 15 months to life in prison. In Egypt, a life sentence is the equivalent of twenty-five years in prison. The charges range from belonging to an illegal group, in reference to the Muslim Brotherhood, participating in illegal protests, inciting violence, using arms against the police, and publishing false news, among others. The majority of the journalists work for outlets that have been critical of the Egyptian government, with many of them reporting for media outlets known to support the Muslim Brotherhood, such as Misr 25 and the Turkey-based Misr al-Aan. The vast majority of the journalists are also accused of belonging to the now-banned Muslim Brotherhood.
Six of the journalists, working for Rassd, Amgad TV, Misr 25, and the Freedom and Justice Gate, were sentenced to life in prison in a mass trial alongside forty-five others. Sentenced on April 11, 2015, the journalists were convicted in the trial known in the media as the Raba’a Operations Room, on charges of “spreading chaos” and “forming an operations room” during the dispersal of the Raba’a al-Adaweya sit-in.
“The arrests of journalists in Egypt are often violent and involve beatings, abuse, and raids of their homes and confiscation of their property,” the CPJ report adds. Journalists are subjected to torture, disappear for prolonged periods, their whereabouts unknown to their families, and their court hearings can take place without notifying the journalists or their lawyers, or without the journalists being permitted to attend.
The majority of the journalists who have been arrested, charged, and sentenced, work for Internet outlets. “The Internet, which could be considered the only space left for free speech and independent reporting in Egypt, is becoming increasingly dangerous,” the report said. The report also highlighted a draft cybercrime bill, which has been approved by the cabinet, but has yet to be approved by President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi. According to CPJ, the draft bill “allows law enforcement agencies to block websites and pursue heavy prison sentences against Internet users for vaguely defined crimes such as “harming social peace” and “threatening national unity.” This, CPJ says, could have “dire” implications for blogger and journalists.
See below for an overview of what the eighteen journalists have been charged with, and the status of their cases, according to the CPJ report:
Name | Place of Arrest | Date of Arrest | Charge | Status | Outlet |
1. Mahmoud Abu Zeid (Shawkan) | Covering Raba’a dispersal | August 14, 2013 | Has not been officially charged. He is being investigated for weapons possession, illegal assembly, murder, and attempted murder | Pre-trial detention | Demotix ` |
2. Samhi Mustafa | Home of Brotherhood leader’s son | August 25, 2013 | Spreading chaos; Forming an Operations Room during the Raba’a dispersal | Life in prison | Rassd |
3. Abdullah Al Fakharany | Home of Brotherhood leader’s son | August 25, 2013 | Spreading chaos; Forming an Operations Room during the Raba’a dispersal | Life in prison | Rassd |
4. Mohamed Al-Adly | Home of Brotherhood leader’s son | August 25, 2013 | Spreading chaos; Forming an Operations Room during the Raba’a dispersal | Life in prison | Amgad TV |
5. Saeed Abuhaj | At day job | November 4, 2013 | Inciting violence, protests; Using arms against police | Sinai
Media Center |
|
6. Hany Salah el-Deen | Airport | November 28, 2013 | Spreading chaos; Forming an Operations Room during the Raba’a dispersal | Life in prison | Misr 25 |
7. Mohamed Ali Salah | Covering Azhar protest | December 27, 2013 | Illegal protests; Inciting violence | Five years, reduced to three on appeal | Al Shaab
al Jadeed |
8. Ahmed Fouad | Covering Brotherhood protest | January 25, 2014 | Joining a group that aims to disrupt the law; Blocking roads; | Trial postponed to October | Karmoz |
Weapons possession; Illegal protests | |||||
9. Mosad al-Barbary | Beirut | April 2, 2014 | Publishing false news in support of Raba’a Operations Room; Spreading chaos, Forming an Operations Room during Raba’a dispersal | Life in prison | Misr 25
Ahrar 25 |
10. Omar Abdel Maksoud | Covering a baby shower of a woman who gave birth in custody | April 15, 2014 | Setting fire to Sisi campaign cars; Belonging to Brotherhood | Life in prison in absentia despite being detained | Masr al-Arabia |
Illegal protests | Two years, overturned on appeal | ||||
Working for Al Jazeera | No trial date set yet | ||||
11. Abdel Rahman Shaheen | On the street in Suez City | April 9, 2014 | Inciting and committing violence during protests | Three years & 10,000EGP fine | Freedom and Justice Gate |
12. Emad Sayed Abu Zeid | His home | September 1, 2014 | Publishing false news;Joining Brotherhood | Three years | Suef Online
Al-Ahram Gate |
13. Mohamed Ali Hassan | His home | December 11, 2014 | Spreading false news; Inciting protests; Funding illegal protests; Belonging to illegal group | Pre-trial detention | Misr al-Aan
Al Nahar |
14. Hassan al-Kabbani | His home | January 22, 2015 | Espionage; Damaging Egypt’s standing abroad; Joining an illegal group; Spreading false news to disturb public peace | Pre-trial detention | Freelancer
Freedom and Justice Gate |
Spreading chaos; Forming an Operations Room during the Raba’a dispersal | Life in prison | ||||
15. Tarek Mahrous | At a cafe | January 31, 2015 | Participating and photographing an illegal protest | Released pending investigation | Misr al-Aan |
16. Ahmed al-Tanobi | Cairo metro station | January 31, 2015 | Incitement against the government; Participating in illegal protest; Belonging to an illegal group | Released on bail | Arab Media Freedom Monitor |
17. Abdelrahman Abdelsalam Yaqot | Outside Fauzi Maath police station pursuing a lead | March 21, 2015 | Possessing explosives; Participating in illegal protests; Belonging to an illegal group | No trial date set yet | Karmoz |
18, Youssef Shaaban | At an appeal hearing | May 11, 2015 | Assaulting police officers; Attempting to storm a police station | 15 months | Al Bedaiah |
Image: Photo: Photojournalist Mahmoud Abouzeid (Shakwan) has been detained since August 2013 without charge (Lobna Tarek/Freedom for Shakwan Facebook page)